Post by account_disabled on Mar 6, 2024 9:14:52 GMT
The discussion about the legal nature of annual fees charged by professional supervisory councils that is whether or not they belong to the tax field and whether they can be fixed through internal resolution had general repercussions recognized by the Federal Supreme Court. The Extraordinary Appeal with grievance was filed by the Regional Nursing Council of Paraná.
When defending the existence of a general repercussion on the matter raised in the appeal the rapporteur minister Dias Toffoli highlighted that the topic is relevant for all professional supervisory councils as it deals with the way in which the value of their annual fees is set. “The discussion taking place in this case therefore has the potential to be repeated in countless processes given that in each of these the interests of the thousands of professionals subject to the payment of annual fees will be at stake” he said.
The minister also recalled that Direct Unconstitutionality BTC Number Data Action is underway at the STF in which the constitutionality of Law is being discussed which allows each professional supervisory board to set and charge its annual fees. The ADI which is also reported by Minister Dias Toffoli will still be considered by the STF Plenary.
In the Extraordinary Appeal with Appeal CorenPR opposes the ruling of the Federal Court of Paraná which limited the collection of annual fees made by the council in addition to determining the refund of amounts charged in favor of a nursing assistant. The questioned decision recognized the tax nature of such contributions preventing the entity from setting them through internal resolution. With information from the STF Press Office.
When defending the existence of a general repercussion on the matter raised in the appeal the rapporteur minister Dias Toffoli highlighted that the topic is relevant for all professional supervisory councils as it deals with the way in which the value of their annual fees is set. “The discussion taking place in this case therefore has the potential to be repeated in countless processes given that in each of these the interests of the thousands of professionals subject to the payment of annual fees will be at stake” he said.
The minister also recalled that Direct Unconstitutionality BTC Number Data Action is underway at the STF in which the constitutionality of Law is being discussed which allows each professional supervisory board to set and charge its annual fees. The ADI which is also reported by Minister Dias Toffoli will still be considered by the STF Plenary.
In the Extraordinary Appeal with Appeal CorenPR opposes the ruling of the Federal Court of Paraná which limited the collection of annual fees made by the council in addition to determining the refund of amounts charged in favor of a nursing assistant. The questioned decision recognized the tax nature of such contributions preventing the entity from setting them through internal resolution. With information from the STF Press Office.